"I was neck deep in water, so I was already freaking out," the actress told Jimmy Fallon, who applauded her professionalism.

Daviss tells PEOPLE he and Cline "realized how little we even just talk to each other on this show" Jonathan Daviss and Madelyn Cline have been friends for half a decade at this point, but it was only this year that they got to have some one-on-one time in front of the camera.